Many agency owners still measure growth by headcount, and every new hire adds cost, complexity and another layer of management. Growing the clients you already have, measuring what matters, automating the busywork and sharpening your positioning can grow profit without growing the team.
I joined Carson Pierce on the Agency Profit Podcast to discuss how the ideas in Paul Jarvis's Company of One apply to agencies, and why staying small might be your smartest growth strategy.
Who Is Albert Banks?
00:01 Carson Pierce: Hello again, everyone. Welcome to the Agency Profit Podcast. My name is Carson Pierce, and today I'm joined by Albert Banks from Apertus. I chatted with Albert not too long ago, we had a really great chat, and we talk about a lot of the same things, so this will be fun. The other neat thing is that we're going to get to do a little bit of book club, which I love the idea of. I won't spoil anything just yet, though. Let's get into some introductions. Albert, please tell me a little bit more about who you are and what you do.
Albert Banks: Absolutely. Thanks for having me on, Carson. I'm a former agency founder and owner. I ran a digital agency for 20-plus years and went through growth bumps, mergers, acquisitions, repositionings and all kinds of fun things along my career. While I was originally a computer engineer, I ended up running the business, so a lot of the back end of the business: finance and operations, talent, IT, office, legal, all those fun things. Now I'm out helping other service businesses, in particular lots of agencies, along their journey, hopefully helping them avoid some of the pitfalls I faced and work through the new challenges we're facing today.
Carson Pierce: I think anyone who's been in the agency world long enough has gone through the whole spectrum of joys and disasters, and anyone who hasn't can learn from those who have. So I'm glad you're here to help share some of that wisdom.
Albert Banks: Absolutely.
Is Headcount the Right Way to Measure Agency Growth?
01:26 Carson Pierce: Book club. Let's do this. When we were talking, you mentioned a specific book you've been looking at, which is Company of One. The subtitle is Why Staying Small Is the Next Big Thing for Business. I haven't read it, so I'm going to learn a lot from this conversation. The idea, of course, is that we don't need to grow in the traditional ways we think about growth. There are different ways to grow.
So I want to explore that with you. We're going to go through a bunch of different points you're taking from the book, which wasn't designed to be about agencies. But I think you and I both do this: we read a book and go, how does this apply to what we're doing? So let's start with the traditional idea of growth. You're an agency owner. You've got these grand ideas of owning a much larger agency with bigger impact and all that sort of thing. Typically, the traditional way of measuring that is by headcount. You can also do it by revenue, but I think those things are pretty tied together. I've certainly worked in agencies where we measured it that way: we want to be at a team size of X at a certain point to represent success. And I think what you're bringing from the book is that that's not the only way to measure growth.
Albert Banks: Right. And look, I read this book because I am a company of one. I was talking to some other consultants who recommended it, and the title sort of narrows it to that. But once you start reading it, it's really about a mindset shift, a different way of approaching decision-making. That's why I felt it could be applicable to agencies, even though it was written a while ago, given the changes we're seeing in our market and our culture and how we need to think about some things differently.
So you're absolutely right. Maybe FTE count was truly a measurable you felt was important in your company, or you were thinking about it in terms of size, because in the past buyers would look at your FTE count and put you in a certain bucket. But there's also the "Oh, look at that company, they're successful. They're up to whatever FTEs." It's a little more aspirational, and Jarvis calls this the disease of more in the book. Because the reality is that when you add headcount, you're adding complexity, cost, responsibility and management layers. While it may be the easiest answer to say, "We have more coming in, or there's more to do, so let's hire more," that's the easy answer: just add capacity. He's challenging you to look for the smart answer, not necessarily the easy one.
What Are the Hidden Costs of Growing Bigger?
03:14 Albert Banks: And there's data behind it. High-tech startups that grow really, really fast most often fail because they grew too fast. Those who scaled more consistently and conservatively at certain stages were ultimately more successful. So there's evidence behind it.
The story I have is with my agency. My first agency was around 10, 12, 15 people, and we ended up merging with a local competitor who was about 35. Obviously that is an FTE count, but together it solved a lot of issues that we couldn't have solved just by growing headcount. We both had a client concentration issue that we solved. We had shared services, like the back end, where I could do the same type of work for both companies. So we were actually better off coming together. If we'd grown separately, we both would have had to add headcount to achieve the same thing.
Carson Pierce: There were a couple of things you touched on there that really ring true when I think about the work I do with agencies. You're talking about feeling like you need to grow in order to succeed, but there's also the feeling that if I shrink, if I reduce my headcount, that's somehow failure. So I think we can dispel that one at the same time. The other thing is, I've seen agencies that grow and aren't really more profitable. They're not putting more money in the bank, but they are getting more stressed and having a lot more headaches. At that point, you have to ask, is it even worth it? So what's the alternative to growing by headcount?
Why Should Agencies Grow the Clients They Already Have?
05:36 Albert Banks: It's funny, I always say you have the same problems, just with more zeros behind them. Growth creates a magnitude you're not really wanting. But there are lots of different ways to go about it. Again, it's about mentality.
One thing is that it took us almost 15 years to realize we had to grow our current accounts. We spent all this time on outbound and on other activities that were never as successful as growing the accounts we had. That's another tenet of the book: customer success. Doing a great job for the clients you're already working with is by far the best approach. It's much more expensive to win a new client than it is to retain one. Oftentimes you're more profitable with the clients you have and are growing, because you already have that familiarity and you understand the work and the demands.
So that's certainly a way to do it. It was successful in our business, and I preach it to anybody I talk to. We were deliberate about it. We tracked those as separate deals. We had an account director who led it, set goals and ran quarterly reviews, and they were even incentivized on it. You can put systems in place to grow without necessarily adding headcount, and there's a bit of security there as well.
How Do You Take On More Work Without Hiring?
07:51 Carson Pierce: You're talking about growing your existing accounts rather than going out and finding new business. That's still growth, though, and you still have to support that work. So how do you do that without adding headcount?
Albert Banks: I'll argue you can squeeze more juice out of the lemon, so to speak. If you have account people, strategists or staff members working on those clients, they're probably not fully at capacity, unless you have the luxury of someone 100% allocated to one client, which is very, very rare these days. Adding more work for an existing client may not require any more headcount. It may just mean better utilizing the team that's already working on that client or subset of clients. So for me, it's about spending more time with the current client. You see revenue grow without necessarily adding headcount, and in theory you also see margin, because your costs haven't increased much.
Carson Pierce: I guess it's similar to people who work on multiple projects. There are all those gaps as you switch from one project to another, context switching and all that, and something is lost there. So the fewer clients you're working with, the more efficient you can be with that time, and the better you get at it.
Albert Banks: That's right, exactly.
How Should Data Drive the Decision to Hire?
09:18 Carson Pierce: Okay, I've got that one. What's another way? I know you have a list.
Albert Banks: Some of it is measuring yourself, having the numbers behind your decision-making. I'm a big proponent of EOS and the scorecard mentality. I say you have 8 to 15 measurements you look at as a leadership team, and I think the book says 5 to 15. But really, the idea from the book is to run in the black as long as you can with the lowest overhead, and to be very, very specific about how you grow. To do that, you need to be measuring what's important to you. You should measure the past, but that's less valuable. You're really trying to get to the point where you measure anything that's predictive of the future, and honestly, anything you'll actually act on. If you're measuring something you're not going to do anything about, what's the point?
That's how we ran it at our agency. As much as possible, we measured the things that were predictive and could help us make decisions, the biggest decision being whether or not to hire. Obviously there are systems behind those things, like your project management or resource management systems, that give you the information and scenarios of what that might look like. But use measurement and use data to decide whether to grow in that traditional sense or not.
Which Metrics Belong on Your Agency Scorecard?
10:46 Carson Pierce: Now you're right in Parakeeto's wheelhouse, so this is what I like. Just for reference, when you talk about EOS, we're talking about the book Traction, if anyone wants to look it up and isn't already familiar with it. It seems pretty ubiquitous, but you never know. What are some of the measurements you like there? Two things come to mind for me. Utilization tends to be the historical number. When we think about utilization, it's measuring backwards. There's also forecasting around it: here's how much work I have coming in, here's how much capacity I have, are we planning to be utilized at the right level? But are there other numbers you're thinking about when you talk about measuring for this?
Albert Banks: Absolutely. If you follow the book Traction, there's a high-level scorecard, like a leadership or agency scorecard, and then departmental scorecards, where you can have more granularity. But if you're talking about the top line, it's about the health of the company, and that has to cover all the different areas.
So sales and marketing: are you measuring to your target? Are you closing sales at the right clip? What's your win rate? Again, I'm big on account growth and retention. What's our renewal rate? How long are our relationships? What's our lifetime value? These are a bit bigger, but you can distill them down into weekly activity to make sure you're trending toward your goal. I was always a big fan of effective bill rate, looking at it paired with utilization and comparing it to cost rate, because that's where your margin is made. And if you can get down to the project profitability level, identifying challenges on particular projects is a leading indicator, well ahead of something like a project's gross margin.
Utilization used to be a big one for me, and I think it still is to some extent, but that's changing in this AI world, which we can talk about. It's still important to me, but the way you look at it, and maybe its priority, has shifted a little over time. I definitely want to include talent metrics, like your team's turnover rate, and if you can, some sort of gut score on culture and how things are going there. I think that's important. Then there's the safety net stuff, like your cash reserve. The bigger it is, the more power you have to make decisions in the near term versus the long term. So it's really about the overall health of the business across all the important areas. I even include the delivery side, like errors and delivering on time and on budget, which is of course very important as well.
Why Measure Effective Bill Rate Against a Target?
13:36 Carson Pierce: You touched on utilization as maybe not the one you like to focus on, and you mentioned effective rate. We always look at those two together, because it's so easy to trade one off against the other. But I think you're right about effective rate. If you look at your rate and realize you're spending double the hours you planned for, that will indicate a bigger leakage than utilization in a lot of cases.
Albert Banks: I'd double-click here. We had an agency average, what our average should be when we looked at our scorecard. But going further down, sometimes you take on a project for different reasons, or you price an engagement in different ways. So we always measured effective bill rate against target bill rate. You may take one on and say, this is a breakeven, a loss leader, an entry point or a favor to an existing client, so your target is different for that one, and you need to measure against that target. Or you say, no, this is a big client, we priced it to the value, not to the cost, so we need to be here. You can't be missing that number. You can't be down here just because it's the agency average. You've got to be where your target is. So not all EBRs are created equal.
Carson Pierce: Exactly. The planned EBR, the one you set as the baseline, is just as important as your actual, because otherwise you don't know what you're measuring against.
How Can AI and Automation Free Up Your Team?
15:32 Carson Pierce: We could talk about numbers all day long, but we'll keep moving forward. One of the other things we're talking about here is the people side, and we're inevitably going to end up talking about AI as part of this too. You mentioned earlier that maybe it's about utilizing your people in a different way. So how do we lean into that in order to grow without just adding more heads?
Albert Banks: In the book, he calls it scalable systems: technology and automation. Again, it was written well before the AI environment we're in now, so it's kind of serendipitous. There's more and more opportunity right now to retool and use software in places where you used to have to use people.
A good example: we used to say account leads can really only handle 3 to 5 clients at a time. Some of that is mental load, but some of it is just the capacity to do things like take notes, analyze those notes, create action items and assign them. AI has already gobbled that up. Those types of things can be handled by the machine, so to speak, so maybe an account person can handle 8 to 10 clients, because that really manual work can be done for them. You could argue whether that's good or bad, and about the mental capacity it takes to understand that many clients. But you now have technology that can take on some of the things humans used to do, so maybe they can spend more time really thinking about the client, forming human relationships and doing the things they probably like better anyway. That's obviously a quasi-billable task.
The other thing is to automate the back office, which is ripe for this. Project setup, some of the bookkeeping, expense management and the rules around it, and some controls you can put in place. There's time you can trim in the back office that could really help. So start with handoffs, like meeting notes, next steps and project setups, and maybe month-end close or data hygiene cadences. You could call it AI, but it's really having systems in place that cut down on the human workload, which allows people to do other things.
Who Keeps the Time AI Saves?
17:50 Carson Pierce: You're saying do other things. What other things are we getting them to do? I think the typical approach is: we're going to automate, we're going to use AI, and suddenly we only need two-thirds of the people we used to need. I guess there are two logical options. One is to let people go, and the other is to sell even more work into the pipeline to keep people busy. Are those the only two options, or are we looking at other things as well?
Albert Banks: This is a hot topic. I talked about it with a bunch of agency owners at an event last week. Say you have a team member who, even on their own, has created automations or processes so that 10 hours of work only takes them 2. Who gets the 8 hours? Is it the employee? "See you, have fun this afternoon." Is it the agency that's paying them? Is it the client that's paying the agency? That's an important question to ask. Coming from that background, I think the answer is the agency.
But to your point, what do you do with that time? I think it's providing more value for that client, or taking the systems the individual has created and democratizing them, implementing them across the agency so the rest of the team gets the advantage. Almost think of it as IP. So in my opinion, it's doing more work for the client or helping the agency improve. I think that works for a while and can continue to work, but you're already seeing price pressure from clients. So you have to have an answer for that and a position on it, so you're prepared for the conversation when it inevitably happens.
Carson Pierce: You said do more work for the client or add value for the client. Isn't that very similar to overservicing? We've saved ourselves time, so we're going to do more. Or do you try to charge more for that?
Albert Banks: I think there's an opportunity in the short term to make more money and more profit. That's true. But it's a limited window until the pricing pressure comes down hard enough. Then it really has to be, "We're truly delivering more," like providing five instead of three, or "We've had a greater impact on a measurable number we agreed on in advance," by doing it this way while keeping the price the same or even pushing it up.
Carson Pierce: I've heard the same thing about clients expecting more and pushing the price down. I think the smart agencies are taking advantage of it while they can and squirreling that money away, because they know it won't last forever.
Albert Banks: That's right. That's a good approach. I also think it's coming around a little, in that you're seeing some pushback on AI slop, or on AI not doing well with high-level strategy or really creative, breakthrough ideas. So some of it depends on what type of agency or business you are and the services you provide, as to how big this impact really is.
Carson Pierce: I've talked to several agencies whose marketing strategy is purposely built around not leaning into AI too hard. They're going to use it for some things, but the idea is that you won't get the same kind of strategy or creative from AI as you will from some really talented humans.
Albert Banks: I'd agree with that. I've spoken to a lot who leveraged AI in their positioning, their marketing, their materials and their communications, and are now really pulling back on it. It was a really fast wave of "AI first," AI this, AI that. They thought it was important, and maybe some clients did too. Now it's, "Isn't everybody doing AI?" Kind of like "Isn't everybody digital?" was several years ago.
Carson Pierce: At some point it just becomes ingrained. When I think about your example of taking meeting notes, it feels like it happened quickly, but also subtly. Ten years ago I was a project manager, sitting in meetings taking notes as frantically as I could, then moving those notes somewhere else after the meeting where they'd get ignored. Now I don't even touch my keyboard or pick up a pen during a call, because it's all automated. I just go into the transcript later and ask it questions when I need to, rather than trying to find something. So that sort of thing has happened, and in some ways we almost take those changes for granted now. Then it's, okay, what's next? Lots of savings there.
Albert Banks: Exactly.
Why Should Your Agency Be Pistachio Ice Cream?
22:06 Carson Pierce: I want to move on to the next point from the book, and you're going to have to explain it, because I saw this point in the notes and thought, I have no idea what he's talking about. It has to do with pistachio ice cream. If you want to explain that, that would be lovely.
Albert Banks: Of course. Growth by default, taking whatever comes to you, gives you a bigger business, but not necessarily one you chose. It's just sort of generic. The point of pistachio ice cream is that it's polarizing. It's not vanilla. The parallel here is that polarizing brands attract passionate customers, while bland ones appeal to everybody. Simply put, this is positioning. What you put out into the world is what you attract. So not everybody should be for you. You should have a narrower ideal client profile: somebody who will really fit with you, will really care about how you go about things and what you do, and will value the price you put in front of them. Opportunities are just obligations wearing appealing masks, so you have to fight through that.
We dealt with this firsthand at my agency, and it took a big disruption to finally get there. In 2020, we lost our biggest client and COVID hit within three months of each other, so that was a fun time. We had been thinking for a long time that "generic digital agency" is what everybody is. Even traditional agencies say that now, and that's been going on for a long time. So we asked, what does the market actually want, and what can we be? And from a business perspective, what type of work will allow us to run a healthy business?
We made a change. We pivoted internally and positioned externally to be more of a data-driven performance marketing and creative agency. We shed our legacy web work, which we'd both grown up with for many, many years and had even done some massive enterprise work in. But we felt that's where the industry was going. Inevitably, that cut out a portion of potential clients, and even existing clients we were doing work for, and it really narrowed who we were and who we could work with. But it allowed us to get the type of work we wanted: work that was retainer-based, predictable and renewable, with a healthy margin. Utilization was in a good place. And we wouldn't have a single massive client, because we were doing some giant project one year out of operating expenses.
So go through that process, really look at yourself and ask, am I pistachio or am I vanilla? Obviously there's everything in between, but the point is, if you're distinctive, you can attract the type of customers you're really looking for.
Carson Pierce: That's a pretty straightforward positioning strategy. However, in the market we're in right now, pipelines are tight and it doesn't feel like there's a lot of work out there. I think a lot of agencies are a bit terrified of narrowing their focus and therefore saying no to any work that's coming in. Right now it feels like everyone's trying to say yes to more and more. Is there space for this strategy in the kind of market we're in right now?
Albert Banks: Look, we had the same conversation back then. Our leadership team brought up the same things. When we shared it with our team members, they said, "Oh God, are we going to have enough work?" I think this is a yes-and. You can publicly say, this is the type of work we do and this is the type of client we want. I believe, and we saw, that it will make you stand out. It will bring more opportunities, qualified opportunities, to your door, and it will save you time in the sales process. That doesn't mean you can't take on serendipitous work. You can still do that, and you can continue with legacy clients until you're ready to transition out. It was probably two or three years before we shed some of our legacy clients and found them a good home elsewhere. So you can do both. You can be the pistachio ice cream while, behind the scenes, if you need to take vanilla work to pay the bills, so be it.
Is It Okay to Stay Small?
27:45 Carson Pierce: Cool. So, summarizing, I'm going to try to go through the five points we tried to cover in this call. First, the idea that we don't need to hire to grow. Second, grow the accounts you already have: rather than taking on new business, look at the accounts you already have and see how you can expand them. Third, measurement. You talked about a lot of different measurements to track this and what we need to pay attention to there, and if you want to talk more about numbers, let's chat. Fourth, automation. We talked about AI and how we can leverage automation to be more efficient with what we're doing. And fifth, differentiation, with the pistachio. Did I cover everything?
Albert Banks: Absolutely. You nailed it.
Carson Pierce: Perfect. Any last thoughts on this idea of growing for the sake of growing, or getting comfortable with not growing?
Albert Banks: Sometimes people say "lifestyle" and treat it like a bad word. I'm more and more in the camp, and I've had conversations recently with owners who are really thinking about staying small. I have a theory, and maybe some math I'll share at some point, about what the dollars and cents look like if you stay and run a well-run business versus exit, with the complications that come with that. So I'd encourage people to really think about what they want. Lifestyle is not a bad word. If it's working for you as an owner and for your team, and you're making money and doing work you love, don't feel the compulsion to do something driven by some external factor.
Carson Pierce: Maybe it's an age thing, but I feel like the younger cohort of agency owners may be more driven by the idea of growing and building a reputation. At a certain point you're just like, you know what, I'm okay if we don't do that. I certainly have agencies on my roster that say, we're fine being five people or whatever it is. They feel good about what they're doing, they don't have the headaches that go with growth, and they're profitable at the same time.
Albert Banks: I think there's a new generation even behind that. I've got a former team member who's building a one-, two- or three-person shop, leveraging AI and starting it a totally different way, fresh. I think his revenue per FTE will be amazing, and he can stay small. So it's about totally rethinking how your business works. That's obviously hard if you're already well established, but there are different ways to go about it.
Carson Pierce: You mentioned this new generation. Do you think the new model for an agency is going to be a really tight team leveraging AI, and the days of large agencies with lots of people sitting in an office are gone?
Albert Banks: Potentially, for a while. Again, I come back to: it depends on what type of work you do. For high-level creative and strategic work, I think the human element is there, and that could be lots of bodies and lots of ideas being kicked around. If that's your type of work, I think it's a different answer. If it's more transactional work, then yes, I think it's more senior creatives, strategists, marketers and technologists leveraging AI in a smaller team.
The inevitable outcry is, then what happens to your junior staff? No one has a great answer for that right now. I'd encourage people not to lose them, because then you'll have a gap. We've seen it in many other industries: if the next generation and younger folks don't get involved, there's a gap and a cliff at some point. So let's not go there. Maybe some of it is taking the savings you've gained from some of the things we've talked about and having more junior team members, who are maybe less billable and are building out some of these AI systems, learning from the seniors, getting good practice or working on pro bono projects. So I think the model will look different, but we have to be very deliberate about avoiding any unintended consequences.
Carson Pierce: We could talk about that for a long time.
Albert Banks: For sure.
Carson Pierce: We'll stop here, though. Before we wrap up, where can people find you online if they want to follow up with you?
Albert Banks: You can find me on my website at apertus.co, or Albert Banks on LinkedIn. I'm happy to chat with anybody who wants to talk.
Carson Pierce: I'm sure you're the only Albert Banks there, so we'll put direct links in the show notes for anyone who finds 1,700 Albert Bankses on LinkedIn. Thank you so much, Albert. This has been a lot of fun. I've learned a lot, and I hope everyone listening has learned as well.
Albert Banks: Awesome, Carson. Thanks for having me on and letting me share this book and how I think it applies to your audience.

